Workers in the construction, servicing, steel and shipbuilding
industries who operate hand-held vibrating power tools, may be at
risk from certain types of vibration induced injuries.
The majority of hand-held power tools transmit vibrations to the
hands and arms. Vibration from certain tools can even affect the
lower back shoulders, neck and head. Portable hand-held power tool
vibrations consist of a reciprocal motion in the handles which
arise when a number of forces with varying directions and magnitude
influence the tools and set them in motion. These forces consist
largely of reaction forces from the work process. In other words,
they arise while the operators perform the tasks that the tools
were designed for.
Workers exposed to vibration as a result of operating portable
hand-held vibrating tools can, if exposed for a long length of
time, usually measured in years, be at risk from injuries
collectively known as the Hand-Arm Vibration Syndrome (HAVS).
One such HAVS injury is Raynaud's Phenomena or Vibration White
Finger (VWF). VWF occurs when vibration is absorbed into the hands
and arms as a result of operating portable hand-held power
tools.
When workers first expose their hands to vibration, they usually
report tingling followed by numbness. After further exposure,over a
number of years, their fingers feel swollen and movement could be
restricted. If their hands are exposed to the cold, their
fingertips will whiten.
Symptoms do not appear immediately, for there is an affiliation
between the appearance of VWF and the subjected exposure time. This
affiliation is called the latent interval. The shorter the latent
interval, the more intense the vibration. After years of exposure
to vibration the thumbs may become white in an attack and the
fingers will eventually turn blue and in some extremities, lead to
gangrene.
For most victims of VWF, its immediate effect is to restrict
quality of life through of loss of feeling and sensation in the
fingers or even hands. All that a doctor can prescribe is a loss of
manipulative dexterity. There is no cure or treatment presently
available for VWF.
The immediate prognosis is to increase the blood supply and to cure
all blanching of the fingers, but without VWF attacks occurring,
especially in cold weather. Long-term aspirin therapy is currently
being investigated because there is evidence that aspirin raises
blood viscosity. Apart from medical research, preventative measures
are the only other means of protecting the worker.
The Health and Safety at Work Act 1974, and the Management of
Health and Safety at Work Regulations 1992, obliges all employers
to do everything that is reasonably practicable to prevent an
individual from being injured by the hazards at work.
International Organisation for Standardisation (ISO) 5349 (1986),
British Standard (BS) 6842 (1987) and the European Community (EC)
Machinery Safety Directive 89/392/EEC (1992) all give guidance on
preventative procedures for hand-arm vibration.
The Machinery Safety Directive came into effect on 1 January 1993.
The directive requires that instructions for Portable Hand Held or
Guided Machinery indicate whether or not the operator will be
subjected to vibration exceeding 2.5m/sec.
The Directive gives manufacturers and suppliers a two year
transitional period within which to comply. The Directive also
proposes that the instruction handbooks for hand-held machinery
should specify the equivalent acceleration to which the hands or
arms are subjected.
Preventative procedures as a means of protecting individuals from
hand-transmitted vibrations should not be the only protection.
Legislation is also badly needed to reduce vibration exposure.
However, the European Commission (CEC) is proposing that the
European Community adopt a directive on 'physical agents'. The
CEC's broad aim is to specify a series of levels of vibration
exposure above which action has to be taken - the required action
increasing with the exposure level.
In addition to ISO 5349 (1986), BS 6842 (1987) and the EC Machinery
Directive (1992), and, if we disregard the possibility of
legislation and the reduction in exposure time, other fundamental
health and safety procedures can be introduced to control hand-arm
vibration.
The first procedure when employers are choosing new power tool
equipment is to purchase tools that incorporate anti-vibration
devices.
Another form of reducing the risk of vibration is to train power
tool operatives how to work efficiently in a safe and healthy
manner. The essential question, however, is one of the
effectiveness of such instruction. The best technique for operator
comfort and vibration attenuation should be identified.
Another important preventative measure lies with the individual
operative. Individual users of vibrating hand-held power tools must
accept the responsibilities needed to maintain good health.
If the operative smokes then that person must minimise their
smoking habit because nicotine in tobacco acts on the nervous
system and the carbon monoxide lessens the ability of red blood
cells to carry oxygen throughout the body. Nicotine can raise heart
rate and increase the effects of high blood pressure. It would
therefore appear surprising if prolonged smoking did not have some
effect on the blood circulation in the fingers and the symptoms of
VWF.
Vibration and VWF are problems that need addressing. Looking
forward to the future, portable hand-held power tool vibration
damping must go hand-in-hand with legislation.
De Montfort University in association with myself is currently
researching a different approach to vibration damping that is both
practical and economical. It is developing a vibration or shock
damping material which comprises of mouldable materials and
particles that attenuate vibrations when applied feed forces are
exerted. The material could have immense benefits for making
handgrips that can be fitted to vibrating machinery.
Until the CEC Directive on 'physical agents' is passed and research
on vibration attenuation developed, industries associated with
power tool use will continue to have problems preventing Vibration
White Finger.