n a snowbound day this year a DJ on Sheffield radio announced: 'The
only things working in Sheffield today are the trams - I've waited
30 years to say that.' Indeed, 30 years on from its demise the tram
is making a comeback - not only on Sheffield's gradients, but
elsewhere too.
On the other side of the Pennines the Greater Manchester Metrolink
is being hailed as a success. After three years it is attracting
20% more passengers than target, 10% of whom used to make the
journey by car, and a substantial 40% 'could have' made the journey
by car.
The new age of the tram dawned in the mid 80s, spurred by
Thatcherite transport policies which favoured the car and led to
city centre congestion. Local authorities were forced to look at
alternatives to the car and the furiously competitive, deregulated
bus services.
In the euphoria of the construction boom, 22 schemes worth
œ2.7 billion were seriously being put forward, as light rail's
bright, modern and environmentally friendly image encouraged local
politicians up and down the country to believe that it had the
answer to congestion in their towns.
'We had a loony boom when everybody wanted a system,' remarked
Scott McIntosh, light rail development manager for London
Transport.
Unfortunately, the goldrush never materialised. The conviction of
politicians - particularly in Government - didn't extend to parting
with cash. In 1992 a House of Commons Select Committee admitted
that the œ400 million pledged to the Jubilee Line by Canary
Wharf's developers had been 'mistakenly viewed as the shape of
things to come everywhere else'. The private sector never came up
with the cash: smaller towns abandoned the idea of trams. But light
rail did not die.
The 'loony boom' was merely replaced with pragmatism. Larger towns
and cities have put together more modest schemes, some integrated
with 'guided bus' services. Today, the serious contenders still
weigh in at around œ1 billion (see section below).
'We needed a more balanced approach to tram systems,' says Tony
Depledge, president of the Light Rail Transit Association and
managing director of Blackpool Transport Services. 'In smaller
towns it would be too expensive. Saddling future generations with
expensive light rail schemes they don't need will bring few
benefits.'
The LRTA is a great advocate of the balanced public transport
system. 'We need to convince a potentially receptive public that
the message is: Go by car when you have to, go by bus or tram when
you can.' Scott McIntosh agreed wholeheartedly. 'Simply building a
tramway is not enough. It has to be part of an integrated
approach,' he said.
The future is not likely to hold too many surprises according to
McIntosh. 'Any government will carry forward the joint
public/private approach. But there is going to be less money spent
on the roads programme and more on public transport whichever
government is in power.'