by Graham Ridout
An investigation is underway to determine the cause of the sudden
subsidence that created traffic chaos on a section of the recently
completed reconstruction of the M40 motorway, which was one of the
first design, build, finance and operate road contracts.
Until the cause of the subsidence is established, it is not known
whether DBFO contractor UK Highways will be financially penalised.
Four instances of subsidence, each approximately 2mx2m and about
70mm deep, were discovered on 10 August after a period of heavy
rainfall and prompted the closure of three of the four westbound
lanes between junctions 2 and 3. Within two days, UK Highways (a
consortium of contractors Laing and Tarmac with consulting engineer
Hyder) had repaired and fully reopened the motorway.
UK Highways' general manager Mike Mercer-Deadman said the cause of
the subsidence is "a puzzle and does not appear to be a design
fault." The section of the motorway that failed was an existing
three-lane flexible construction carriageway that had been widened
to four lanes and strengthened by the addition of an 100mm overlay
comprising a 50mm asphalt base course with a porous asphalt wearing
course.
One suggestion being investigated was whether the subsidence was
caused by a "swallow hole" in the underlying chalk substrata which
suddenly collapsed as a result of the heavy rain.
UK Highways completed the 24-month reconstruction programme in
January 1999. Under the terms of the contract, UK Highways can be
"fined" for excessive or unscheduled lane closures. The amount
depends on the time of day of the closures and the amount of
traffic using the road.
Mercer-Deadman said that it was not yet known whether any penalty
would be levied, adding that UK Highways and client the Highways
Agency were "still considering the issues."