by Tim Wood
Small- and medium-sized builders are continuing to suffer from the
after effects of the Construction Industry Scheme, the
controversial new tax system, with more than two-thirds
experiencing recruitment problems as a direct result.
The latest state of trade survey carried out by the Federation of
Master Builders has revealed that many of the respondents had
experienced so many problems that they feared being driven out of
business because of the lack of profitability. The CIS has also
reduced the availability of skilled tradesmen with many opting to
work for themselves or shifting into the black market, often in
direct competition with those companies for whom they had
previously worked.
The survey, covering the first three months of 2000, also showed
that the number of firms reporting an increase in workloads has
gone up by 9%. However, the modest increase, mainly in the repair,
maintenance and improvement sector and commercial work, is
underlined by there being no leap in total employment levels and an
easing of delays in obtaining supplies of materials.
The answers from 360 FMB members also showed that 34% of builders
remained optimistic that increased orders will continue into the
second quarter, while others had expressed their concern over the
longstanding effects of the CIS and the continuance of the punitive
VAT rate.
Commenting on the findings, FMB president Derrick Ovington said:
"Although we welcome the increase in workload, the business
environment for many of our members continues to be difficult with
the ill-thought-out CIS resulting in unnecessary red tape and
problems with recruiting labour. In addition, by not reducing the
level of VAT on domestic RMI, the Government has failed to address
the black market activities of the cowboy operatives against
registered builders.
"The negative impact of CIS and burgeoning black economy on the
industry takes the edge off this modest increase in workload. An
increase in workload is of small comfort if there is no profit
incentive."