The proposed retrofitting of diesel particulate filters (DPFs) to
construction equipment working in Greater London by 2006 could
compromise the machines' CE certification and performance,
according to the Construction Equipment Association (CEA).
In a damming response to
the proposal from the Partnership in Reducing Emissions from
Construction Equipment (PRECIS), the CEA said many
filters would have to be fitted externally and could cause the
machines to breach EU noise and visibility regulations.
"This whole issue, while having merit in aiming to improve air
quality, raises significant issues for building contractors, plant
hirers and users," said Tim Faithfull, director of member services
at the CEA, which represents plant manufacturers.
Faithfull said OEMs are not currently in position to factory fit
DPFs (required by Stage IIIb legislation in 2010) and they could
not recommend any modification that would cause a machine to be in
breach of EU certification.
According to the CEA, DPFs are duty-cycle specific and each machine
and application would require a unique solution resulting in high
retrofit costs - probably more than £1,000 and possibly more
than £2,000. Tailoring the DPF to a job also inhibits moving
machines from one site to another and poses problems for plant hire
companies.
The CEA is calling for an exemption for plant in cases where the
retrofitting of a DPF would cost more than 10% of the machine price
as this would make these items unviable.
It also wants exemption for machines below 75kW or 10t operating
weight.
Unless run on ultra-low sulphur diesel (another proposal from
PRECIS), the DPF would rapidly clog. The availability of ultra
low-sulphur red diesel would lead to a considerable reduction in
some emissions without the need for a DPF, the CEA said.
"Those in the industry should not think that this is just a London
initiative - it will almost certainly be adopted by other cities,"
Faithfull said.